Skip to main content

Deflategate: In Defense of Tom Brady

I am a huge fan of the NFL, and I also recognize that players are extremely underpaid in comparison to the value they generate.

in-defense-of-tom-brady

Another Day, Another Scandal

Scandals are nothing new in sports, and very often, they are quickly forgotten as something new emerges. But when it comes to America’s favorite spectator sport, the National Football League (NFL), the scandals never seem to end. If the scandal involves its best team, the spotlight never dies. That was very true for the New England Patriots and what became known as Deflategate, the accusation that QB Tom Brady ordered the team’s equipment staff to under inflate the footballs below League standards.

Fans quickly split into three camps: Brady was 100% guilty, not guilty, and an apathetic group whose sentiment can be summed up as, “Who cares? Let’s play football.” Many players, particularly a dozen or so recently retired, spoke out against Brady. However, it quickly began to sound a lot like sour grapes. There would be thousands of amateur physicists and referees checking footballs over years, coming up with different theories.

The League’s investigation did nothing to quell the controversy; in fact, the final report made it worse. Brady has never been cleared of any wrongdoing, but it appears this practice of underinflation was not all his invention.

in-defense-of-tom-brady

In the Beginning

During halftime at the AFC Championship Game on January 18, 2015, between the Indianapolis Colts and the New England Patriots, league officials examined the inflation levels of the game balls used by the Patriots, 12 total. NFL rules allow each team to use their own footballs during a game. Nearly half were found to be below the minimum standard of 12.5; some less than 11.0. Game ball inflation between 12.5 and 13.5 pounds per square inch (psi). The balls had not been checked prior to the game nor at any time during the first half. So the balls were reinflated and put back in the game. The Colts game balls were also examined and found to be within specifications. However, it is believed that cold temperatures make the inflation drop by nearly 2.0 psi. Although the balls are checked before a game, that pressure is not recorded.

The NFL denied any prior knowledge of this issue. But Colts GM Ryan Grigson, speaking in 2016, stated to reporters that their equipment staff had obtained a couple of the Pats’ game balls during a week 11 matchup in 2014. Their defense had nabbed two via interceptions. When they examined the balls, they felt different. So, they were checked and discrepancies noted. Grigson claims he told the League about this long before their Conference Championship; a juicy bit of info that Commissioner Roger Goodell did not want revealed.

After the Super Bowl in 2015, the League ordered an investigation led by attorney Ted Wells. His final report came out in May 2015 and remains controversial to this day. After a year of legal wrangling, Tom Brady served a four-game suspension during the 2016 season.

Hating Success

The odds of Brady actually making it in the NFL were slim for a gawky, un-athletic (for football) 6’ 4” 215 pound slow as molasses backup QB from Michigan who was laughed at while at the NFL combine. A sixth-round draft choice (pick # 199) whose combine appearance bordered on the embarrassing usually means swift irrelevance. But Brady is an example to everyone, especially young people, that hard work is the driver of success. Michael Vick famously stated that his biggest regret was not working hard enough or preparing for games when he first came into the League. Johnny Manziel said something similar during his ill-fated time in the NFL. No kidding. If other QBs had one ounce of the discipline and energy of Brady, they might be headed to the Hall of Fame too.

The hate towards Tom Brady goes way beyond just our jaded sports culture. It is symptomatic of the class envy and the overall trolling of success that has infested our society. Life has become once endless sequel to Mean Girls. We scorn accomplishments and just generally dislike someone who has achieved more than anyone else. This is bad for everyone. Why must everyone “be equal?” We aren’t. Either through genetics, hard work or luck, it can’t happen. Someone will always be better than you at something. Deal with it.

Super Bowl XXXVI - The First

Patriots' kicker Adam Vinatieri celebrates his game winning kick.

Patriots' kicker Adam Vinatieri celebrates his game winning kick.

Brady at the combine. Does he look like an NFL QB?  I don't think I'd pick him for my company softball team.

Brady at the combine. Does he look like an NFL QB? I don't think I'd pick him for my company softball team.

Underrated

Nobody should feel sorry for this guy. Let’s face it, Brady was the guy in high school who always got the hottest girl, had the nicest car, and was lauded by coaches and teachers just because he was Tom Brady. He probably stole a girlfriend or two from some of his classmates. Growing up in comfortable circumstances, the son of an insurance executive, doesn’t hurt either. It still doesn’t give anyone the right to impugn his character based on innuendo nor guarantee a starting job on an NFL roster. You still have to want it and work for it.

After a mediocre college career at Michigan, he was drafted #199 in the 2000 NFL draft (a compensatory pick). His ratings at the combine were so low that Chad Pennington, Giovanni Carmazzi, (who?) and Marc Bulger were drafted ahead of him. Carmazzi hurt the most because it was Brady’s childhood team, the San Francisco 49ers, who drafted him.

in-defense-of-tom-brady
Scroll to Continue
in-defense-of-tom-brady
Drew Bledsoe as a Patriot

Drew Bledsoe as a Patriot

Destiny

In his first season, Brady hardly saw the field; going just 1 for 3 in his lone opportunity to play. At the start of camp, he had been the fourth QB on the depth chart, barely making the team. By the start of the season in 2001, he was the backup to Drew Bledsoe. The veteran Bledshoe had led the Pats to a Super Bowl four years earlier under then coach Bill Parcells. Bledshoe was an established QB in the NFL. Popular with fans and teammates, he had a proven track record as a starter. He was nearly as popular in the Boston area as Nomar Garciaparra of the Red Sox and Paul Pierce of the Celtics. He even helped mentor Brady after he made the team. But fate stepped in and changed the lives of both men.

Bledshoe was hurt in Week 2, going down with severe internal bleeding from a bad hit. He came back for a series but had to be taken out due to severe pain. Brady finished the game and started the following week. Belichick declared Brady the starter for the rest of the season. The NFL is a tough business and cold-hearted decisions are made every day. This was no different.

Although he started out slow his first two or three starts, by Week 7 he was starting to show the Tom Brady everyone would eventually know. Leading them through the playoffs and getting lucky with the now infamous “tuck rule” fumble recovery against the Raiders in the divisional playoffs, they won Super Bowl XXXVI. However, in a strange coincidence, Bledsoe had to replace Brady in the AFC Championship due to injury. Bledshoe showed the old magic and the team responded. Brady came back for the Super Bowl, and they won on a last second field goal by Adam Vinatieri.

That’s when the legend of Brady’s work ethic began to take shape. Stories emerged about his drive and discipline. Rodney Harrison, the notoriously hard-hitting veteran safety for the Pats, often speaks of his days with the Patriots. He would find Brady in the weight room at 6am during the week. Brady would greet him with mocking scorn about “being late.” Rodney says he tried to get there by 5:30 and still Brady beat him. No matter how early, Brady would find out and arrive before everyone else. That’s leadership by example and dedication.

Close, But No Cigar

2007: The perfect season that wasn't.

2007: The perfect season that wasn't.

The Pats won two more Super Bowls in 2004 and 2005; the last team to win back to back. In 2006, the Pats went to the AFC championship game again, but this time they did not have home field. Peyton Manning and the Colts finally beat them, going on to win his only Super Bowl.

In 2007, they added Randy Moss and Donte Stallworth among others to the roster. They went 16-0 in the regular season and won their first two playoff games. Then in one of the biggest upsets in history, the Pats lost to the New York Giants in Super Bowl XLII. David Tyree’s miracle catch helped set the stage for Plaxico Buress’ touchdown. I jumped up and down like a little kid. Still, I have to hand it to the Pats; going 18-0 up to that point is an amazing accomplishment in the modern era.

During that season controversy erupted over Spygate, the now notorious taping scandal. In September, they were accused by the Jets of videotaping their defensive signals which was against League rules. It was former Belichick assistant, and then Jets coach Eric Mangini, who made the accusation. Belichick admitted to it the next week (sort of) and was fined half a million dollars. It was bush league. Would they have won the game anyway? Yes. Did Brady know about it? Not until after the fact. Even if he did, what could he do about it? NFL players have very little power. Brady still had to study film on his own and make the throws as well as check downs.

In 2008, Brady went down with an Achilles tear and the Pat missed the playoffs. He came back again in 2009, had a solid season but lost in the playoffs.The 2010 season went like the previous ones, with the Pats winning the division but losing in the playoffs. They got back to the Super Bowl after the 2011 season only to lose to my Giants once again. Now getting to 5 Super Bowls is an astonishing feat. Yet he still had his detractors. Was he finished? This is the end, many declared back in September. Well, it wasn’t. And winning Super Bowl XLIX proved it. At 37, he tied Joe Montana’s record.

What is the biggest difference between Montana and Brady? Brady did it with different rosters and over a longer period. Free agency did not go into full swing until after Montana retired. Those Niner teams had a core that remained intact for almost a decade. Brady and Belichick had free agency and cap issues to deal with every year.

The Infamous Call That Started It All

Tom Brady during the "Tuck Rule" incident on January 19, 2002.

Tom Brady during the "Tuck Rule" incident on January 19, 2002.

Former QB Brad Johnson paid his ball boys to tamper with the footballs too.

Former QB Brad Johnson paid his ball boys to tamper with the footballs too.

Tipping Point

A group of ex-players criticized Brady and called him “tainted.” One even added that he was a man “without honor and integrity. This is jealously laced with a good dose of hypocrisy. The criticism did not stop with ex-players. Varous public figures and media members piled on over the next year. Some of it had nothing to do with inflating footballs.

In 2008, Jemele Hill of ESPN wrote an article calling Brady “Teflon Tom,” because no one made an issue of his out of wedlock child with actress Bridget Moynhan like they have done with other players. Hill was trying to convey, in a backhanded manner, that there is a subtle racism in the way the media portrays Brady and out of wedlock births. She was right. But that doesn't change the facts. Brady is active in all of his children's lives and makes all his child support payments.

Deflating footballs? Other QBs have already admitted doing it. In fact, one Super Bowl winning QB, Brad Johnson of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, admitted to tipping the ball boys prior to playoffs games in order to get the footballs exactly how he liked them. Other QBs have the equipment guys rub down the laces to wear them out a little. It helps with grip. So why the outrage for Brady? Envy can lead many astray.

Questionable Case of Detractors

The list of people questioning Brady is a group that really needs to check themselves and look in the mirror:

  • Ray Lewis, football analyst – Probably the best linebacker of his generation. Hall of Famer. So he can question Brady’s on-field performance. But off the field, he should audible. He has a very questionable alibi for a double murder, and he also has six children by four women, Still, he calls Brady tainted; a man without honor. Well, he needs to define the word honor again for me. Don’t throw stones, Ray. I don’t care if you’re in the Hall of Fame for what you did on the field. Once you question someone’s integrity, it’s personal.
  • Charles Haley - The Hall of Famer and the only other player besides Brady with five Super Bowl rings (Cowboys and Niners), now says Brady is tainted as a cheater. Haley, who has been diagnosed with bipolar disorder, once peed on the Niners President’s desk because he was mad at him. Treating people like crap was a way of life for Mr. Haley. Sexual harassment, attempted assault on a sportswriter and threats were par for the course. As much sympathy as I have for his mental struggles, he needs to shut up and turn the page.
  • Marc Brunell - A solid starting QB for almost a decade with the Jacksonville Jaguars, added to the chorus Super Bowl week. Coming from a moderately successfully QB, this seems like sour grapes. I always rooted for guys like Brunell (especially when left-handed), however this is ridiculous. Tom Brady would beat Brunell throwing beach balls. And on top of that, Brunell is a very religious guy. Making accusations goes against his teachings. You can judge, but put it in context, Mark. Judge not lest you be judged. Any time you want, check out Brunell’s Super Bowl highlights…oh wait, there aren’t any. Unless holder on field goals counts.
  • Jerry Rice - The Niners great called Tom Brady and the Patriots cheaters. Then he admitted to using Stickum during his career. For the uninitiated, stickum was a substance used by NFL players in the 1970s and 1980s that was later banned. Once the ball hit that substance on a players gloves or arm, it stayed there. Lester Hayes, the All pro cornerback for the Raiders back in the 80s, was its most famous user. But Rice used it after it was banned. So the great Jerry Rice was also a cheater, by his definition. On top of that, he used the old excuse: everyone did it. Chris Carter and Michael Irvin both refute that claim. Hey Jerry, Lance Armstrong on Line 1.
  • Jerome Bettis – The Steelers great was sitting next to Brunell on the ESPN panel and agreed that he was a cheater. Ridiculous. Bettis got one ring because his QB, Ben Roethlisberger, saved his butt after a goal line fumble against the Colts. Big Ben chased down and tackled the guy who recovered it. Without that now famous play, Bettis would be thought of in the same vein as Ernest Byner. Jerome, you’re fat and happy, let it go. You were inches from infamy.

    And the list goes on...

    Others who joined in the criticism include Troy Aikman and Brian Dawkins. While I respect Aikman a lot, his vitriol is very misplaced. Again, I suspect it’s because Brady has had a better career. As for Brian Dawkins, no one cares. He can go out to lunch with Mark Brunell and talk about not winning a Super Bowl. Maybe they can go half on tickets for the game.

    I’m usually happy when players come out and are willing to criticize other players for transgressions or bad decisions on the field. It’s refreshing. I wish former coaches did the same with their brethren. But calling someone dishonorable goes a bit too far for me. Whenever there's an off the field incident involving a player, I hear so many others calling for patience and saying over and over again, “We don’t know all the facts.” Jealousy got in the way this time.

    The media who cover the NFL on a regular basis have played it down the middle, for the most part. Talk radio is a different story. Even the columnists have shied away from declaring "deflategate" a scandal. However, there have been exceptions. One of those is New York Times sports columnist William C. Rhoden. He has been pounding the drum on how Tom Brady is "arrogant;" even appearing on the CBS morning show to defend Roger Goodell. The game's integrity was at stake according to Rhoden. This from a guy who previously called for the commissioner's impeachment.

    Rhoden has praised both Ray Lewis and James Harrison in past columns. That's odd because both men have had some questionable incidences in their past: Lewis for abetting a murder and Harrison for domestic violence. I'm big on second chances and have absolutely no problem with both men moving on with their lives. However, for that same columnist to come out and be apoplectic about underinflated footballs is bizarre. It is unbecoming of a New York Times writer. But Rhoden is the same guy who left a Wimbledon Final to go see a Will Smith movie.

Gang Tackle

Mark Brunell and Jerome Bettis calling out Tom Brady.

Mark Brunell and Jerome Bettis calling out Tom Brady.

Brady with Pats owner Robert Kraft after another playoff victory.

Brady with Pats owner Robert Kraft after another playoff victory.

The Penalty

Nothing has changed for me. The destruction of his cell phone is dumb but who cares. Now that we know that ESPN's Chris Mortensen was handed a false story by Mike Kensil, the NFL's Director of Football Operations, the story stinks even more. Mortenson claimed that 11 of 12 footballs were underinflated. That was an out and out lie. The haters are piling on Brady.

in-defense-of-tom-brady

Brady Moves On and Up

On July 15, 2016, Brady released a statement saying it was time to move on and that he would not take the case any further. The next stop would have been the Supreme Court. I would like to have seen him keep fighting. But the players' union may have had a say in that as well. Let the hate continue.

So Brady was suspended for the first four games of the 2016 season. The result: the Patriots went 3-1 with their two backup QBs. They eventually finished 14-2 overall with Brady having another stellar season. He was sitting on the cusp of another Super Bowl and the league realized they had awoken a sleeping giant.

in-defense-of-tom-brady

Getting It Wrong

All these years later, new information has been uncovered that has finally put to rest any doubt that Deflategate was a fraud. In his book, Playmakers, NBC’s Mike Florio reveals who was the tipster for Chris Mortenson and discusses the science that puts a lie to the NFL’s findings. Florio has deep sources within the League office and his narratives on the front office politics involving League Officials have become legendary.

Mortenson’s sources turned out to be ex-player turned NFL’s Executive Vice President of Football Operations, Troy Vincent. He relayed to Mort that 11 of the 12 footballs tested failed the supposed standard. While it is unclear if Vincent deliberately gave him false data, we do know how the scandal started. This led to that now infamous press conference where Brady was asked if he was a cheater.

However, most importantly, science now confirms what a joke the NFL’s investigation was during this entire period.

in-defense-of-tom-brady

The Ideal Gas Law

The formula for this law defines the state of an amount of gas as determined by its pressure, volume and temperature. The equation PV = nRT. With P = pressure, V = volume, n = the actual amount, R = ideal gas constant and T = temperature.

But what does all this prove and how does it help Brady? At the start of the 2015 season, the NFL began performing air-pressure spot-checks during halftime at all games. The numbers were collected by the League with the expectation that they would never see the light of day. The weather had a great effect on ball pressure. The pressure inside the balls would rise on warm days, and fall on cold days. In the fall, temperatures can drop during a game significantly, leading to great disparities in pressures.

According to Florio, numerous” measurements made at halftime of games during the 2015 season generated numbers beyond the permitted range of 12.5 to 13.5 psi, with the reading showing a direct correlation between temperature and air pressure:

On cold days, pressure readings taken before the balls were moved to the field resulted in lower readings after 90 minutes of exposure to the conditions. On hot days, the pressure increased.

The League had the numbers to get the Patriots off the hook. But what happened to that data? Florio's source claims the NFL expunged the numbers on orders from general counsel Jeff Pash. If only we had penalty flags for executives.

Was everything above board with Patriots too? Probably not. But deflategate was certainly not worthy of suspensions and an embarrassing investigation.

in-defense-of-tom-brady

Super Bowls, LI, LII, and LIII

SB LI

I've watched 41 Super Bowls (maybe more on my dad's lap) and I thought I've seen it all. But this game left me speechless. Of course, it involved the Patriots. But I did think it was over mid-way through the 3rd Quarter. I know many want to blame the Falcons, but it was Brady, Belichick, and Hightower that took that game away. Brady's composed demeanor along with his simmering anger led them to another victory. The entire country was stunned. He became the greatest of all time. No one close. I will admit one thing: he did not deserve to be MVP. James White should have gotten it.

SB LII

For once, I was rooting for the Eagles. Their fans deserved a Lombardi Trophy. Winning with a backup QB is an amazing accomplishment and Nick Foles is the kind of feel-good story all sportswriters love. Most the country was hoping he'd play well. But Brady was awesome in defeat, throwing for over 500 yards and three touchdowns. He also broke his own record for most passing yards in a Super Bowl. It was an amazing game. Brady lived up to his legacy but this time the defense failed him.

SB LIII

Brady and Belichick reached number nine, and in many ways the game disappointed. In a season when the NFL set scoring records, it was the lowest scoring Super Bowl in history. Belichick, the defensive guru, against the new, upstart offensive "genius." The only touchdown came in the 4th quarter. But Brady completed just enough passes, most of them to Julian Edelman, to score 13 points and win the game 13-3. Brady now has 7 rings; he has appeared in 10 Super Bowls. There is no denying his the greatest of all time.

The Debate Is Over

The arguments will continue to rage about who is the greatest QB of all time. But the NFL is all about Lombardi Trophies. Brady has the most. He just completed his 22nd season and now has a ring without Belichick. Instead of being envious of his success, young players need to study him and learn how to be successful. Hard work and laser-like focus, along with absolute dedication to fitness are the secrets to his success. He is not the fastest, nor the smartest or the most physically gifted. You can't measure heart at the combine. Twenty years ago, he was dismissed as a prospect. Now they're getting a bust ready at Canton.

When someone makes it to the pinnacle of his or her profession, we shouldn't always be looking to tear them down. Let's celebrate success. Our society would be better for it.

Sources

Brady, James, “Jerry Rice criticizes Patriots for cheating, admits to using stickum on his gloves.” SB Nation, February 7, 2015. http://www.sbnation.com/nfl/2015/2/7/7996115/jerry-rice-cheating-stickum-patriots-deflate-gate.

Deckart, Brett. “NFL Quarterbacks: Race Still a Factor, According to ESPN’s Jemele Hill.” BleacherReport, November 24, 2010.

Florio, Mike. Playmakers: How the NFL Really Works (And Doesn't). New York, PublicAffairs, 2022

Hill, Jemele. “Ladies Love Tom Brady – no matter what.” ESPN.com, January 31, 2008. http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/page2/story?page=hill/080129

Kussoy, Howie. “Ex-players react: Brady’s cluelessness unbelievable.” New York Post. January 22, 2015.

McCue, Ian. “Tom Brady looked like a lost fan at the 2000 Combine.” Nep.247sports.com. February 17, 2015. http://nep.247sports.com/Bolt/Tom-Brady-looked-like-a-lost-fan-at-the-2000-Combine-35691138.

Pennington, Bill. “Eli Manning’s Footballs Are Months in Making.” New York Times, November 23, 2013.

Pierce, Charles., Moving the Chains: Tom Brady and the Pursuit of Everything. New York, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2006. ISBN0-374-21444-1

Rosenberg, Michael. “As Deflategate rages on, Tom Brady’s story simply doesn’t add up.” Sports Illustrated, January 22, 2015 (updated Jan. 23). SI.com.

Smith, Michael David. “Brad Johnson: I did tip ball boys, but I did nothing wrong.” Pro Football Talk, January 21, 2015.

Terranova, Justin. “Aikman on Deflategate: Brady knew and Belichick should burn.” New York Post, January 22, 2015.


Comments

CJ Kelly (author) from the PNW on January 28, 2017:

Thx BL. I hope it's an awesome Super Bowl. I'm torn. I want Goodell to have to give Brady the trophy but the Falcons winning would be great for the game. It might even make Atlanta a real sports town. :)

BODYLEVIVE from Alabama, USA on January 28, 2017:

He knows what he's doing and he's on his way to showing the world what he's all about.

CJ Kelly (author) from the PNW on October 18, 2016:

Greatly appreciate the kind words from a New Englander. You're correct, no one has the right to question his work ethic and results.

Glenn from Greater Burlington, Vt on October 18, 2016:

Hey Lions44;

This is a great post. I'm from Vt., but was a 49'ers fan during the Montana / Rice / Lott / Craig era, and rightly called them the greatest ever.

Now, I'm a New England fan, a Celtics fan, a Patriots fan and a Brady fan, and I agree that nothing should take away from his work ethic and his performance.

Glenn

CJ Kelly (author) from the PNW on March 30, 2016:

Thanks, Tim. Greatly appreciate the kind words. The longer the NFL drags this out, the more sympathetic he becomes.

Tim Lajoie from Lewiston, Maine on March 29, 2016:

That's a great piece...well done!

CJ Kelly (author) from the PNW on March 21, 2016:

Thx, MK. Glad you liked. He's such a polarizing figure, I was not expecting a compliment. :).

madugundu krishna from Yemmiganur on March 19, 2016:

interesting, it is a wonderful analysis.

CJ Kelly (author) from the PNW on April 04, 2015:

Hi Mr. Davis. While I agree the money corrupts in terms of bending the rules, I think it also leads to envy. And in the case of Brady, extreme envy based on his success which generated his dream lifestyle. But he did it through hard work. Did his coach bend the rules? Yes. But Brady still had to put the work in and nobody works harder. Deflating the balls is the equivalent of a spitball. My point is that for other pro athletes to criticize him is ridiculous. They did the same things. Thx for commenting.

DW Davis from Eastern NC on April 04, 2015:

I have no real faith in the honesty of anyone involved in professional sports. There is just too much money involved. They are going to bend the rules every which way they can to gain an advantage, and break them when they think no one is looking and they think they won't get caught. The amount of money involved just makes it impossible to believe otherwise.

CJ Kelly (author) from the PNW on March 25, 2015:

Frank, thx very much. Good luck w/your Jets. Draft a QB.

4FoodSafety, I think I'm going to post that Brady combine photo on my FB page to make a point to all the Brady haters. Thx and stay well.

Kelly Kline Burnett from Fontana, WI on March 25, 2015:

Fascinating and very well researched! Thank you very much! The photo of Brady from the 2000 NFL Scouting Combine is amazing and a reminder that we all must start somewhere.

Frank Atanacio from Shelton on March 25, 2015:

as much as I hate The Pats.. they have one of the finest QB in football history.. naw i don't think he is a cheater.. wish my Jets had someone like that on my team.. great sports views..loved it my friend :)

CJ Kelly (author) from the PNW on March 02, 2015:

Thanks, Larry. Really appreciate it.

Larry Rankin from Oklahoma on March 02, 2015:

Wonderful analysis.

Related Articles