Fantasy SportsTeam SportsIndividual SportsAnimal SportsThe Olympics

Greatest Yankees Sluggers of All Time

Updated on September 22, 2017
Nashville G-man profile image

I am a publicist, freelance writer, and musician. I've had my music licensed by the Houston Astros for their team videos.

The Yankees are the most storied franchise in all of sports, having won 26 World Series titles since 1923. It goes without saying that some of the greatest power hitters in baseball history have worn Yankees pinstripes. Let's take a look at the top home run hitters in franchise history. This list is based strictly on total homers with the team, meaning players like Reggie Jackson are left off.

Best Yankees Sluggers

  • Babe Ruth
  • Mickey Mantle
  • Lou Gehrig
  • Joe DiMaggio
  • Yogi Berra
  • Bernie Williams
  • Graig Nettles
  • Don Mattingly
  • Dave Winfield
  • Roger Maris

Babe Ruth

Is there a single player in history that is more synonymous with Yankees baseball? After coming over from the Red Sox in 1920, Ruth stopped pitching (he began his career as a pitcher with Boston) and instead became an everyday outfielder. With 659 franchise home runs (714 total), he ranks first for the all-time record as a Yankees slugger and third in baseball history. Ruth played for the Yanks from 1920 to 1934. His two best seasons were 1921 (59 homers, 171 RBI, .378 batting average) and 1927 (60 homers, 164 RBI, .356 batting average). He helped the Yankees win four world championships and seven American League pennants. He was a charter member of the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame. He signed with the Boston Braves as a free agent in 1935 before retiring after that season.

Mickey Mantle

The Mick played his entire career in a Yankees uniform from 1951 to 1968. He clubbed 536 home runs during that time. The outfielder had his best season in 1956 when he hit .353 with 52 homers and 130 RBI. In addition to leading the Yanks to 12 pennants and seven championships, he also won three American League MVP Awards, was a 16-time All Star, and led the league in homers four times. Mantle retired in 1969 and was inducted into the MLB Hall of Fame in 1974.


Lou Gehrig

First baseman Lou Gehrig was a native New Yorker who got to play for his hometown team his entire career (1923-1939). He became one of the greatest players of all time. While Gehrig is known for his consecutive games streak of 2,130 and for a career batting average of .340, he also had incredible power. He slugged 493 homers, including 23 grand slams. The latter is a record that still stands today. He won the American League MVP Award in both 1927 and 1936. His best season may have been in 1934 when he hit 49 homers with 165 runs batted in and a .363 batting average. This earned him the Triple Crown. Unfortunately, Gehrig's career and life was cut short because of ALS, which later became known as Lou Gehrig's Disease.

Joe DiMaggio

He had two nicknames, Joltin' Joe and The Yankee Clipper. He certainly deserved them both. Not necessarily known as a power hitter, DiMaggio is most remembered for his 56-game hitting streak in 1941. The record still stands today and is believed to be a record that no one will ever break. But his 361 home runs rank him fourth for the all-time record with the Yankees, the only team he ever played for (1936-1951). DiMaggio won the American League MVP Award three times. His best season was 1937 with 46 homers, 167 RBI, and a .346 average. The outfielder also led the team to nine World Series titles and 10 American League pennants.


Yogi Berra

Lawrence Peter "Yogi" Berra was one of the greatest hitting catchers of all time. He played his entire career with the Yankees (1946-1963) except for a very brief stint with the Mets in 1965. He also went on to later manage both New York teams. As a player, Berra won the AL MVP Award three times and helped lead the Yanks to the World Series championship 10 times. He hit 358 career homers and his best season was in 1950 when he hit 28 four-baggers with 124 RBI and a .322 batting average. He was elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 1972. In addition to being a great player, Berra is also known for his prophetic sayings such as, "It ain't over till it's over."


Bernie Williams

Bernie Williams played his whole career with the Yankees (1991-2006). The fact that he's ranked sixth for all-time home runs with the club certainly says a lot. He has hit 287 career homers, including 30 in the year 2000 to go along with 121 RBI and a .307 batting average. Williams helped lead the Yanks to four World Series titles and six AL pennants. He also leads the franchise in postseason home runs (22) and RBI (80).

Graig Nettles

Third baseman Graig Nettles played for six teams, but the bulk of his career was spent with the Yankees from 1973-1983. Nettles was a big reason the Yanks won World Series titles in 1977 and 1978. They also made it there in 1976 and 1981. Though he only hit .253 during his tenure in New York, Nettles was a proficient slugger who belted 250 home runs over that time. He also was one of the best fielding third basemen to ever play the position. He won the Gold Glove in 1977 to go along with his best offensive season as a pro (37 homers and 107 RBI). Nettles went on to play for San Diego, Atlanta, and Montreal before retiring in 1988.


Don Mattingly

Another adored Yankees player, first baseman Mattingly played his entire career in New York (1982-1995). Nicknamed Donnie Baseball, he was a terrific hitter who batted at .307 with 222 home runs for his career stats. He won the AL MVP Award in 1985 to go along with nine Gold Glove Awards. That '85 campaign saw Mattingly hit .324 with 35 home runs and 145 runs batted in. Unfortunately, the Yankees bookended his career with World Series appearances (1981 and 1996) but never made it past the first round of the playoffs (1995) during his tenure with the team. Mattingly is currently the manager for the Miami Marlins.


Dave Winfield

Outfielder Dave Winfield played for several teams, but his best years were as a Yankee in the ‘80s. He belted 205 homers with the Yanks, including a career high of 37 with 106 RBI in 1982. At the time that Yankees owner George Steinbrenner signed Winfield in 1981, he was the highest paid player in the game at $23 million over 10 years. Winfield retired from the game in 1995 and was elected to the MLB Hall of Fame in 2001.


Roger Maris

Though he only played in New York for seven seasons (1960-1966), right fielder Roger Maris hit 203 homers with the team. He is best remembered for belting 61 in 1961, a major league record that stood for 37 years before being broken by both Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa. He also had 142 RBI in 1961 despite having a .269 batting average. Maris helped the Yankees win two World Series titles and five American League pennants during his time with the team.

Honorable Mentions

  • Bill Dickey
  • Jorge Posada
  • Tino Martinez
  • Derek Jeter
  • Paul O'Neill
  • Charlie Keller
  • Tommy Henrich
  • Bobby Murcer
  • Tony Lazzeri
  • Jason Giambi
  • Joe Peptitone
  • Reggie Jackson


    0 of 8192 characters used
    Post Comment

    • profile image

      Dustin 6 years ago

      Mickey hitting home-runs lefty and righty you cannot beat that my friend!

    • profile image

      Woot 7 years ago

      Actually i understand why Reggie wouldn't be put on here. In his '77 season for the yankees he had a sub par RBI, mostly because of Billy Martin messing around with the batting lineup. His contract, three million dollars I think, was something that wasn't heard of before, and for his performance was a gross overpayment. He also didn't have the best glove. His shining moment was the World Series of 77 when he hit three consecutive homers. But altogether, he's kind of par or just above par, but not like Ruth, DiMaggio or Mantle

    • mhuze profile image

      mhuze 7 years ago from USA

      Best baseball players of all time for sure.

      My husband and I love the Yankees! Great blog!

    • profile image 7 years ago

      I'm surprised you have Bernie Williams on this list as he wasn't necessarily a prolific home run hitter. If longevity wasn't a criteria in your list you probably could've also included A-rod & Alfonso Soriano.

    • profile image

      kevin 8 years ago

      this is an excellent page, and definitely just helped me crush someone in an argument about how yankees don't have homegrown players... thanks

    • Nashville G-man profile image

      Nashville G-man 8 years ago from Madison, Wisconsin

      hey noniesap....please read the first paragraph before making an ignorant comment like that. This list is based on numbers only and Reggie didn't play long enough with the Yankees to make this list.

    • profile image

      noniesap 8 years ago

      This is bull crap. You have Maris, Nettles, (who played for a gazillion teams) and Winfield all non orginal Yankees, and not Reggie Jackson, who wrote this crap?

    • gksquire9 profile image

      gksquire9 8 years ago from America

      Baseball is back! Thanks for the hub. Time for me to start writing new stadium reviews.

    • profile image

      william 9 years ago

      That is a very good alltime Yankees team.Though i would have had Secondbaseman's Joe Gordon who was a homerun threat for the yankees in the late 1930's and in the 1940's and Alfonso Soriano who was a major homerun threat for the Yankees in the early 2000's.He had 38 homeruns for the AL champion Yankees in 2003.Also Thurman Munson the 300 hitting gold glove catcher for the Yankees in the 1970's who was also a homerun threat should be mentioned.Also i would of mentioned the 300 hitting gold glove right fielder for the 1950's Yankees in Hank Bauer who could hit some homeruns he batted 320. for the world champion 1950 Yankees.Also i would have mentioned Firstbaseman's Hall of Famer Johnny Mize a major homerun slugger who helped the 1950 Yankees to a world championship.Then there was Moose Skowron who was their firstbaseman for most of the 1950's another homerun slugger for the Yankees.Gil Mcdougald who had a good glove at shortstop and secondbase who also hit homeruns in the 1950's for the Yankees i would have to mention as well.

    • profile image

      Joe 10 years ago

      A well put together article which would prove to be very informative to the casual Yankee fan - good luck over the next few days vs. Cleavland - the Yanks jut might win three in a row!