Skip to main content

Reasons for the Green Bay Packers' Success

Paul has been a Green Bay Packers fan all of his life. He remembers seeing Bart Starr, Paul Hornung, and Jimmie Taylor play in the 1960s.

From January 2011 until January 2012, the Packers were the best team in the NFL. As we all know, they won the final two games of the regular 2010 season and then won all of their playoff games, becoming Super Bowl XLV champs. During the 2012–2015 regular seasons, they made the playoffs every year. What made them so successful? This article will suggest five key reasons.

Throughout their long history, the Packers have been one of the most successful NFL teams. In my lifetime, I have lived through three eras of Green Bay supremacy.

  • The first era is chronicled as the Vince Lombardi/Bart Starr glory years of 1959–1967. During this period, they were league champs in 1961–1962 and 1965–1967. They won the first two Super Bowls in 1967 and 1968.
  • The second era of excellence didn't come until about 25 years later during the Mike Holmgren/Brett Favre years of 1992–1998. Green Bay regularly made the playoffs during this time and went on to two Super Bowl games, winning the championship in 1997.
  • I am fortunate to be experiencing the present third era, which began in 2006 and is now being led by Matt LaFleur, Brian Gutekunst, and Aaron Rodgers.

5 Factors Behind the Packers' Success

All three of these eras demonstrate the same characteristics for success. These are the five key reasons for their success.

  1. An Excellent General Manager
  2. An Excellent Coaching Staff
  3. Player Leadership
  4. Good Team Chemistry
  5. Excellent Fans
Ted Thompson, former general manager of the Green Bay Packers.

Ted Thompson, former general manager of the Green Bay Packers.

1. An Excellent General Manager

Ted Thompson became the Packers' general manager on January 14, 2005. He replaced Mike Sherman, who was both head coach and general manager. Before coming to Green Bay, Thompson had been the vice president of operations for the Seattle Seahawks from 2000 to 2004. He had also been the assistant director and director of pro personnel for the Packers from 1992 through1999.

Drawing on his previous experience and association with Mike Holmgren, who had been coach of the Seahawks, Thompson helped make the team successful champs. This was primarily done by his evaluation, drafting, and signing of players, as well as with the hiring of excellent coaches. He also judiciously resolved the Brett Favre retirement dilemma before the 2008 season, which played a major role in enabling Green Bay to establish itself under Aaron Rodgers.

Draft Picks and Signings

In his first draft of 2005, he selected future Super Bowl MVP Aaron Rodgers late in the first round. In the following years, he selected other stars such as A.J. Hawk, Greg Jennings, B.J. Raji, and Clay Matthews. During his first few years with the team, he signed a few key free agents such as Charles Woodson and Ryan Pickett.

After seeing success in the development of most of his draft picks, Thompson opted to not sign expensive free agents but rather use the money to resign his own best players such as Aaron Rodgers, Jordy Nelson, and Randall Cobb. Besides draft choices, he also signed a lot of young, talented, undrafted players who have contributed to the organization, making them one of the youngest teams in the NFL.

Coaching Changes

A year after becoming general manager, Thompson fired Mike Sherman as head coach and hired Mike McCarthy, who had been the quarterback coach for the Packers in 1999 and had more recently been the offensive coordinator of both the San Francisco 49ers and the New Orleans Saints.

Before the 2009 season, Thompson also hired Dom Capers as the defensive coordinator and mastermind for a new 3-4 defense. Capers had previously been the defensive coordinator for the Pittsburg Steelers between 1992 and1994. He also had experience as a head coach, leading the Carolina Panthers to the playoffs in 1996.

Dealing With Favre's Retirement Dilemma

Thompson met his most challenging test before the 2008 season. After leading the Packers to a defeat in the NFC championship game earlier that year, quarterback Brett Favre decided in March that he was going to retire. Thompson took Favre at his word and decided to move on with Aaron Rodgers, who had backed up Favre for three years.

Shortly before the season started, when Favre changed his mind and decided not to retire, Thompson traded Favre to the New York Jets. Many Packer fans thought he did the wrong thing in not taking Favre back. However, he decided that it was in the best interest of the team to move on without Favre. In hindsight, he was correct. No single player is more important than the needs of the whole team, which must come first.

Mike McCarthy, former head coach of the Packers.

Mike McCarthy, former head coach of the Packers.

2. An Excellent Coaching Staff

Head Coach

Green Bay's coaching staff, from the head coach and offensive coordinator Mike McCarthy down to all the assistant position coaches, had been excellent. McCarthy had been so successful because he knew how to work with quarterbacks, call plays, and design an offense that could attack any kind of defense. He was also a motivator who could gain the respect of his players. A few days before Super Bowl XLV, he had his whole team fitted for Super Bowl rings. He wanted his players to believe that they were going to win the game.

Defensive Coordinator

On the other side of the ball, Dom Capers had been an excellent defensive coordinator. He had been a genius at designing defensive schemes that could shut down any offense. He had been especially good at designing defenses with disguised multiple blitz packages and coverages. He was exceptionally good at making use of the talents of his best players like Julius Peppers and Clay Matthews, as well as having everyone help out each other.

Assistant and Position Coaches

Both McCarthy and Capers had excellent assistant and position coaches on the team. For example, on the offensive side, James Campen had done a good job working the offensive line. Edgar Bennett had done well coaching the receivers. On defense, outside linebackers coach Kevin Greene and inside linebackers coach Winston Moss had been outstanding in developing young players such as Clay Matthews and Desmond Bishop.

Quarterback Aaron Rodgers was a Super Bowl XLV champion and MVP.

Quarterback Aaron Rodgers was a Super Bowl XLV champion and MVP.

3. Player Leadership

As well as the general manager and coaches have selected and trained players, it is ultimately the performance of the players on the gridiron that wins games. Besides talented players, every team needs leaders on both offense and defense.

Leaders on Offense

Aaron Rodgers and guard Josh Sitton have been two uncontested leaders on offense. Rodgers plays no favorites and is doing everything he can for the needs of the team. He has been spreading the ball around to all of his talented receivers. When his teammates mess up a play, he is not afraid to let them know. This was seen when he took the tight end, Jermichael Finley, to task for running bad passing routes in a Bears game a few years ago.

Sitton played an important position as a guard and was the leader on the offensive line. He recognized all defensive alignments and called out blocking schemes to other line players. He played excellently both as a leader and an all-pro while with the Packers.

Leaders on Defense

Charles Woodson and Clay Matthews were both the heart and soul of Green Bay's defense. Woodson is listed as a cornerback, but he did more than that in games. Based on different defensive alignments devised by Capers, Woodson would line up anywhere on the field and frequently blitz the quarterback. He was a very intelligent player and set an example by giving more than 100% every play. He would never quit on a play, much like outside linebacker Clay Matthews.

Both players were very intense and intelligent, and they worked well together and with the team in making their teammates better players.

4. Good Team Chemistry

A team can have a bunch of good players, but if they are selfish and don't play well together, they will not be very successful. The Packers have great chemistry now, thanks to the coaches and player leadership. No team member has been suspended since the season began. All players know their roles, and they have only one goal, which is to do anything they can for the good of the team.

5. Excellent Fans

It has been said that fans can be the 12th man on the team. Green Bay fans give the Packers an advantage, especially when they are playing at home. Lambeau Field has sold out every game since 1960. At home games, the fans cheer so enthusiastically that it can be hard for the opposing team to hear their quarterback calling signals. Packer fans also follow their team around the country to away games. Also, there are fans throughout the country who root for the team when they are on the road. The Packers truly seem to be America's team.

Success Depends on the Whole Team

Ted Thompson, Mike McCarthy, Aaron Rodgers, and Charles Woodson are some of the most important people responsible for the success Green Bay had in the 2010s, just like Vince Lombardi, Ron Wolf, Bart Starr, Brett Favre, Reggie White, and Mike Holmgren were in the past. All of these people have demanded excellence and made the Green Bay Packers one of the most successful teams in NFL history.

What Do You Think About the Green Bay Packers' Success?

© 2011 Paul Richard Kuehn


Paul Richard Kuehn (author) from Udorn City, Thailand on June 17, 2013:

Au fait,

Thank you very much for reading and commenting on another Packers hub. I follow all Wisconsin pro sports teams. Considering the problems that the Brewers and Bucks have, I should be happy that the Packers are still halfway decent. Now, if only the Packers can establish a running a game and improve their defense, the Super Bowl might be possible. Thanks for the sharing and pinning of this hub!

C E Clark from North Texas on June 16, 2013:

A very insightful article that Packers fans should enjoy reading. Voted up, interesting, and will share and pin!

Paul Richard Kuehn (author) from Udorn City, Thailand on May 08, 2013:


Thank you very much for reading, commenting, and sharing this hub. Hopefully, the Packers will be even better this year and make it to the Super Bowl!

moonlake from America on May 08, 2013:

I agree completely. "GO PACKERS" Voted up and shared

Angela Brummer from Lincoln, Nebraska on June 09, 2012:

Thank you I will now sounded like I know what I am taking about!

Paul Edmondson from Burlingame, CA on November 17, 2011:

I don't know if any team over the last several years has drafted as well as the Packers. I think that's one of the top two reasons they're as good as they are now.